On November 10th, 2025, the U.S. Mint released the long-awaited 2025 250th Anniversary Marine Corps Privy Silver Eagle—and as expected, it sold out in seconds. With a limited mintage of just 100,000 coins, this release marked one of the most anticipated collectibles of the year, honoring 250 years of Marine Corps history and service.

But what’s unfolding behind the scenes may make this coin even more desirable than anyone initially imagined.

What’s Really Happening at the Mint:

The 2025 Marine Corps Privy Silver Eagles were struck at the Philadelphia Mint, a facility that has long struggled with Proof coin quality control—especially when it comes to achieving perfect PF70 grades.

This year’s production, however, is proving to be by far the worst.

Early grading results from Advanced Release submissions are showing dramatically lower yields of PF70s than we’ve seen from any recent Proof Silver Eagle release. Multiple grading services have confirmed that the percentage of coins achieving perfect grades is significantly below normal levels.

It’s been such a rough rollout that the U.S. Mint has removed the delivery date for the First Day of Issue (FDI) coins from its system entirely and marked the product status as “TBD” (to be determined)—something we’ve never seen before.

What This Means for Collectors:

This situation could have major implications for the market.

• PF70 coins will be much scarcer than previous years.

• Prices are expected to soar as collectors realize how few perfect examples exist.

• The Mint’s delays mean uncertainty for FDI releases, while Advanced Delivery coins—already graded and in-hand—become even more valuable.

The Good News:

At LCR Coin, we already have Advanced Delivery coins physically in stock and available for immediate shipment.

However, our remaining supply is extremely limited—and once they’re gone, replacement costs will be higher. Our new allocation cost alone has already increased by $150 per coin, and future deliveries aren’t expected until late December.

For customers who pre-ordered First Day of Issue coins, rest assured: your orders are locked in at your original price. We’re simply waiting for the Mint to stabilize production and announce a firm delivery date.

More Affordable Options Available Now:

While PF70 prices are climbing fast, we do have PF69 examples available now for collectors who want to secure one of these historic coins at a more accessible price point.

Available now:

• 2025-P Silver Eagle 250th Anniversary U.S. Marine Corps Privy – NGC PF69 Marine Label

• 2025 250th Anniversary Army/Navy/Marine 3-Coin Privy Set – NGC PF69

Final Thoughts

The 2025 Marine Corps Privy Silver Eagle release is turning out to be one of the most unpredictable and talked-about U.S. Mint launches in recent memory. Between the Mint’s production struggles, low PF70 yields, and skyrocketing market demand, this coin’s rarity and value potential are unlike anything we’ve seen in years.

If you’re serious about owning one of these historic pieces—or completing your 250th Anniversary Privy collection—don’t wait.
Advanced Delivery inventory is nearly gone, and once our current stock sells out, replacement costs will be substantially higher.